Thursday, 31 October 2013

Ethics and the new media

Media Ethics and the New Media:
                                          This is closely related to what currently is happening in our country in the pretext of elections, rape cases, corruptions charges and so on so forth. With the growth of digital media over 5 years it is possible to know the entire world in the click of a button. A study claims that digital media will play a decisive role in the 2014 election.
If Face book were a country, it would be the third most populated country in the world. Recently, a claim was made that users of this digital social media are going to have a decisive voice in the results of the imminent general elections of the world's largest democracy and the second most populated nation, India. While there is no denying that Indian users of social media are growing exponentially, a significant say in swinging the ballot, is still in the realm of future possibility rather than immediacy.
                                           This is because it is understood that the current generation is digitized not only in thoughts but in action and so we often find our politicians taking case on twitter and face book to get maximum support of the youth. Another interesting thing we all notice everyday and actively participate is online petitioning, new but a very effective tool for galvanizing people online. Every other day, a new mail drops into the inbox asking you to 'change the world' by signing a petition. It can be as serious an issue as seeking justice for an acid attack victim or as trivial as asking people to get a roadblock removed. For an increasing number of urban Indians bred on concepts of equality and justice but frustrated by trappings of age-old power hierarchies of this country, the idea is promising. You don't need to be a kurta-wearing social activist sitting on dharnas or a donor writing cheques to fund campaigns. Just filling in your name, email Id and postal code would do.

Petitioning around social campaigns has been in practice for decades but never has its impact been more pronounced than today when a call to 'stop rape' can gather 59,000 signatures in just 24 hours (On last count, the petition had 6.64 lakh signatures). For every signature, the decision makers get an email (many petitions also request the supporters to call the officials) thus ensuring constant pressure on them to act.

                                 But is it actually helping us to bring change in Our Real world through the Virtual World? NO in fact, e-petition promotes slacktivism or armchair activism which is also the reason it is so successful. It gives “false power” to those who feel helpless in face of problems they can't control and prevents many of the supporters from participating in on-ground action.



Media ethics and politics

The 2014 elections are being considered to be the biggest ever decisive elections or the most popular election of India .Why? Because it is Narendra Modi or NaMo versus Rahul Gandhi? Is it so? Is this the first time we are encountering there politicians? No both have their eminent place in politics of India and have carved a niche for themselves .Then why it would be called as the most popular election? The answer is quiet simple as simple as the functioning of Indian Media. It would, no it will definitely be a popular election because “two super powers, one has struggled a lot has done many mistakes in the past but promises a good future to the youth and the other is called as the “shehzaada “in politics who uses emotional stories of his life to woo the public in his rallies “–these are some of the common headlines we read or watch on news channels and without forgetting the impeccable debates by Barkha Dutt and Arnab Goswami.
                             The same Rahul Gandhi was considered to be Indian’s youngest intelligent and thoughtful Prime Minister when he entered politics few years back and now with entry of NaMO he has been of late sidelined .Same was the case when NaMo was termed in a way responsible for the 1993 bomblasts was criticised severely by the media. This clearly shows that our media follows a pattern of change perhaps because this is what people want’ A Change’

                        The ethics followed by media it highly questionable when responsible channels like AAJ TAK and Times Now create their own mock elections which is in a way manipulating the election to vote. It is a fact that there channels use portals of new media like Face book and Twitter to assimilate and decide the inclination of their votes .But. this can highly be manipulated as firstly mock votes are usually put by young generation and through new media like internet and not their physical presence in the booths, so it becomes easier for any set of people to mock vote for any party .Secondly, mock votes can be highly fake, manipulated, bought to project one party’s coming victory or failure depending upon the self interest of the new media. Thirdly, although internet is most accessible it is still not available to rural masses which clearly says that the mock results are highly one sided and depended upon the opinion of the educated, but we forget a basic fact that more than 455 population in India is completed illiterate with no knowledge of technology.Lastly, when these mock results are out they create a stereotype in the minds of the public thus in a way manipulating their actual votes of future.

The New Media Ethics and its history through Gandhi:


Although the New Media follows its own code of ethics, it’s definition has drastically changed over the years .Lets take the example of Gandhi, although he was criticised for his political decisions sometimes but, needless to say apart from being a national leader he was a very prolific leader and yes, a great mass communicator .People of new generation may never agree this as for the current generation power is implicitly related violence. But, one should realise the fact that, in an era where Media was just starting to keep its baby steps, he was already established as a media or medium of knowledge and information to the masses. He believed in order to form a public opinion it is very important to first make the people aware of themselves. In order to ventilate the grievances of Indians at that time and mobilise public opinion (which is the sole duty of any media); he started writing and giving interview to different newspapers thus proving a point that it is very important for any media to be available at its best to galvanize people into action.
                       He explains his experience with different newspapers like ‘Indian Opinion’, in his biography “The story of My experiments with truth.” ,which says that he learnt the art of self –restraint while expressing his opinions about the atrocities that were faced by him and other Indians. This is actually a good message for all media professionals in terms of ethics that there should be a sense of self control on what you write ,it is good to express but not at the cost of someone’s’ integrity. He used the newspapers as the vehicles of crusade against the untouchability and poverty in rural areas which again gives a message to all media professionals like you and me that ‘the main aim of any media is not to create war but to fight against it, which is not followed today as I feel that media today acts not only as a scapegoat but also triggers and give enough reasons for any two parties to be enemies for their self interest.
                        I belong to a new generation and I am into media. I have certain rights but I have more duties and the duty is to serve public. If a person like Gandhi who accepted all his mistakes and still strived hard to take up journalism for practicing his mission of journalism why cannot we be a media which upholds public interest and not self interest? If Gandhi, being the only one to run press and newspapers that to without any advertisements manage to galvanize people in an action towards public service; why cannot we the New Media with the help of torrent of advertisements to support us at least be Truthful to the masses who have given us the title of “watchdog” over all kinds of atrocities?
                     He says that “THE SOLE AIM OF JOURNALISM SHOULD BE SERVICE. THE NEWSPAPERS IS GREAT POWER BUT JUST AS AN UNCHANIED TORRENT OF WATER SUBMERGES THE WHOLE COUNTRYSIDE AND DEVASTATES CROPS, EVEN SO AN UNCONTROLLED PEN SERVES, BUT TO DESTROY .IF THE CONTROL IS FRON WITHOUT IT IS POISONOUS SO, THE CONTROL SHOULD BE FROM WITHIN”
         Therefore it somewhere gives us a clear message that it is our duty to educate masses and so it is our prime responsibility to follow certain ethics but from within and should consider three key considerations for our journalistic practice and they are Editorial independence, Adherence to truth and Truth.



Wednesday, 30 October 2013

Contemporary media & Ethics

Indian press today is over 220 years old. Indian Radio is about 100 years old and Doordarshan is about 50 years old. In Jan 1780, James Augustine Hicky started the first newspaper, a weekly, variously called as the Bengal Gazette or the Calcutta General Advisor or Hicky Gazette. He is still regarded as the father of Indian Journalism.
Before Independence, Media was a mission. Its mission was to free India from the clutches of foreign rulers, the British. There were many restrictions on Media in the form of regulations. The infamous gagging act was brought to suppress the vernacular press, for example, is one such regulation. After Independence to there have been many commissions but those were to streamline the working conditions of journalists; categorization of news papers into small, medium and large; commercial orientation for revenue earning by radio; constitution of press council; establishment of national level news agencies and the like.
Radio in India, as an organization is only 2 years behind British Broadcasting Corporation. Now it is terrestrial radio or sky radio reaching 100% geographical area of Indian subcontinent.
Television developed for a mere local cast of Adult education program in 1959 to Krishi Darshan for agricultural extension education in 1967. From the landmark SITE (satellite instructional television experiment) in 1975 to transmission extended to all parts of the country during Asiad games that too in color. Now it is DTH and IP TV covering all parts of the country. Private channels are innumerable with more than the required freedom.
If we look at the various functions of the Media, they are Information, Interpretation, Education, Entertainment and Evaluation. Media informs the people on what is happening around. It interprets the issues for the benefit of the people. It educates the people on various schemes, plans and programmes of the Govt. It entertains the people through various arts and cultural forms. It also evaluates the functioning of the systems in the society.
Gandhiji said "A free press should be neither an ally nor adversary... but a constructive critic". Media is the bridge between the ruler and the ruled for transport of information inputs. The Media, particularly the Press, the Radio, the Television and the Cinema together or independently have the potency to either reform or deform the Society.
But what is happening today? Media that was a mission before independence grew as a profession after independence and of late it is being criticized for becoming a business without ethics and without any social responsibility. It is because the owners of print and private electronic channels are the owners of either a business establishment or an Industrial house or a financial institution. News, naturally in the hands of these businessmen became a commodity. News, which shall be a bare fact is now angled or slanted to make it marketable news. Media wanted stories in place of plain news based on facts. Editorial has become either dictatorial or propriatorials.
It is therefore, often being quoted as "bad news is good news and good news is no news" We read newspapers, listen to radio and watch TV to find a murder, a molestation of a minor girl, an atrocity, a celebrity's divorce, an unholy alliance, a bomb blast, a vehicle plunging into depths, an insurgent attack, an encounter, a political coup, a plan crash where people died or hurt or made to suffer rather than the news on development. Very recently an electronic channel captured an event where a chain snatcher was beaten up by the mob, a policeman tied him to his motorcycle and dragged. It happened in Bihar State. Those visuals were telecast repeatedly creating a kind of vexation in the minds of onlookers. In another incident where a celebrity shook hands with the policemen led to their suspension. It happened in Maharashtra State.
Looking at Media from this point of view, we have to ask ourselves whether Media is in its right direction or going in a wrong way leading the society along with it. The answer would be "Society is the cause". Any Institution or Organization or mission or profession is the reflection of the very society and its individuals. Individual is a measure of the Society.
If the society wants bad, media shall be ready to supply it. If the society demands for good, the media shall make such arrangements. It all depends on the society and its individuals and their taste being the consumers of news. Some experts visualize that very soon a particular medium or its programs will be accepted if they are good and will be rejected if it is bad. But before it could happen sufficient damage will be caused to the Society.
Now the question is who shall change? Should media change or reform it-self to discharge its social responsibility? Change it for the welfare and happiness of the public at large? Or the Society shall change for the better. For this, a set of values and a code of ethics are necessary for both Society and the Media.
Press council of India that is supposed to enforce values and ethics in print medium is said to be teeth less. It has to be rejuvenated. There is no regulation on electronic media. The owners of the Media will have to be oriented towards adoption of values and ethics. The Society being a composition of many individual ethnic groups belonging to various cultures, religions, various levels of economic status, in order to put this on right path all the concerned viz political leaders, social leaders, opinion leaders, religious teachers shall strive for restoring values and ethics in Society.
Media reflects Society. Contemporary media is reflecting the society in its entirety. Therefore, the Government, the Political Parties and the Media Owners etc shall make efforts for restoration of values and ethics in the Society.



Ethics & Research

Nature of ethics
The word “ethics” is connected intrinsically with questions of correct conduct within society. Etymologically, “ethics” comes from the Greek “ethos” meaning “character” which indicates a concern for virtuous people, reliable character and proper conduct. “Morality” is derives from “mores” or custom -- the rules of conduct of a group or society. An initial definition of ethics, then, is the analysis, evaluation, and promotion of correct conduct and/or good character, according to the best available standards.

Ethics asks what we should do in some circumstance, or what we should do as participants in some form of activity or profession. Ethics is not limited to the acts of a single person. Ethics is also interested in the correct practices of governments, corporations, professionals and many other groups. To these questions, ethics seeks a reasoned, principled, position. An appeal to existing practice or the command of a powerful leader is not sufficient. To answer such questions in a consistent, reasoned manner may take us far a-field. Some ethical questions will require reflection on our basic values and the purpose of human society.

Ethics is best conceived of as something we “do,” a form of on-going inquiry into practical problems. Ethics is the difficult practical task of applying norms and standards to ever new and changing circumstances. Ethical questions arise most typically in cases where there is genuine puzzlement about what should be done in various types of situations. There is usually some practical importance or urgency to such questions. Is it ethical for journalists to reveal their sources to the courts, despite their promises of confidentiality? Is it ethical of journalists to invade the privacy of politicians to investigate allegations of mis-behaviour? One inquires ethically because one is puzzled about how existing principles might apply in a concrete situation. Ethical inquiry exists because tensions inevitably arise over what constitutes correct conduct or fair practice wherever humans live and work together. Disagreements arise not only over specific practices, but also over the interpretation of principles.

Ethics is sometimes identified with an inflexible set of rules and self-righteous moralizing. Rules say an action is either right or wrong. This over-simplifies ethics. Ethical thinking requires the guidance of principles but it should not be shackled to them. Instead, we should evaluate principles according to whether they are useful in dealing with ethical concerns. Principles, and their interpretations* change over time. No principle can anticipate all possible situations, and principles may conflict. Ethics should focus on how people interpret, apply, balance and modify their principles in light of new facts, new technology, new social attitudes and changing economic and political conditions.

Ethics is not static. Ethics consists of dynamic frameworks of principles and values. Our ethical values reflect our deepest convictions and attachments. They define who we are, and give us an ethical “identity.” Ethics is the process of inventing new and better ethical responses to problems and conflicts. This process is driven not only by social change but also by our “ethical imagination” which continually pushes on existing boundaries. For example, relatively recent ‘imaginative’ proposals include the advocacy of same-sex marriage and the idea that animals have “rights.” 


Range of ethics
Ethical inquiry covers a wide range of possible subjects, such as:

•  Personal ethics: e.g. questions about one's basic values and plan of life
•  Professional ethics: principles and practices of major professions
•  Social and political ethics: e.g., issues of social justice, political rights
•  Ethics of sexual and gender relations
•  Research ethics in academia and the private sector
•  Environmental ethics, including the ethical treatment of animals
•  Global ethics: ethics of international affairs, human rights
•  Communication ethics, including media, public relations and journalism

Theoretical and applied ethics
Ethical inquiry can occur on many levels of thought, according to one’s focus and interest. We can distinguish between two main types of ethical inquiry:

Theoretical ethics: The study of the main concepts and methods of ethics. Major questions at this level include the nature of ethical language, the justification of ethical judgments and the nature of ethical reasoning. Ethical philosophy, for example, is the systematic study of ethical experience and the justification of moral notions, beginning with those that historically and by current estimation are the most important.

Applied ethics: The application and evaluation of the principles and norms that guide practice in particular domains. The focus is on issues and problems specific to the field in question, through a combination of theory and practice. Major questions at this level include how certain principles apply to various practical problems, the ranking of principles, the standards of “best practice” and ethical decision-making in the field. The “theoretical-applied” distinction is not absolute. It is a matter of emphasis and interest. As practical, reasoned inquiry, ethics in any domain will include both practical and theoretical considerations.

Professional ethics is a major division of applied ethics. It is the application and evaluation of norms and practice in the various professions, such as medicine, journalism and law. Since the mid-1900s, many institutes, centres and journals have been established to study and enhance nursing ethics, business ethics, biomedical ethics, media ethics, the ethics of government and corporate governance and so on.



Types of ethics

By focusing on a major aspect:
One way to approach ethics is to focus on one of four recurring aspects of ethical situations: rights, goods, virtues and our communal relations with others. Ethical inquiry into correct conduct involves (1) questions about whether an action honours or violates anyone’s rights or duties, (2) questions about the “goods” that should be pursued, often thought of as the harmful or beneficial consequences of action, (3) the impact of action on the “virtue” of the actors -- their character and integrity, and (4) the impact of action on our communal and “caring” relations with others.
Each of the four aspects provides an approach to ethics:
1. Teleological or “goods-based” ethics: Ethics is primarily about the aims or telos of actions -- the “goods” to be pursued, including the impact of actions on individuals or groups. Ethics systems in this tradition include “consequential” theories that attempt to maximize valuable outcomes or “goods” and minimize harms. One form of consequentialism is utilitarianism, where valuable outcomes are defined in terms of utility.
2. “Duty” or “de-ontological” ethics: Ethics is primarily about the rights and duties of agents, which take precedent over individual feelings or inclinations, the wishes of the majority, or utilitarian calculations about what would make most people happy. Rights trump the pursuit of goods. There are fundamental principles and duties that restrain self-interest. Ethical systems in this tradition include the philosophy of Kant and John Rawls.
3. Virtue ethics: Ethics is primarily about developing a virtuous person and citizen. Ethics is not primarily about formulating an unchanging set of principles. It is about developing ethical character and the practical wisdom to choose the right thing to do in complex situations. Here, ethical education and development plays a central role. Ethical thought in this tradition derives from the virtue ethics of Plato and Aristotle, with its stress on achieving the good life, through virtuous dispositions. Often, such thinking is “perfectionist” by stressing that ethics should be guided by a notion of human perfection or the ideal society.
4. Ethics of care and community: Ethical deliberation should prioritize the fostering of responsible, caring relationships among people – relationships that honour their dignity, humanity and “connectedness.” This approach is embodied in a “communitarian ethics” that views values as embedded in community and shared practices. According to this approach, too much of Western ethics has emphasized the rights of atomized individuals while downplaying their duties. A primary ethical imperative, then, is to build communities that enhance compassionate and fulfilling relationships among its members. In journalism, this “ethics of care” is expressed in several ways, including the principle to “minimize” unnecessary harm to vulnerable subjects of news stories. Advocates of an ethics of care tend to prefer the “social responsibility theory” of the press over the liberal theory of the press.

Monday, 28 October 2013

The ethics in today's time.

Ethics are a set of things that come from within and are made for the betterment of the society. But today we see that it has been facing problems because of the unethical being injected everywhere in the society. Media too is suffering from the same problem, today people have discovered ways where they try erasing the line which created difference between ethical and unethical. Now a days everything that is done to complete a task is treated ethical.
So to make it more simple the definition of wrong and right is same today, and thus if you are cheating or taking short cuts at the cost of completing your task its no wrong now. We all know that how are ethics treated today and have a lot to criticize it but at the same time we never see the reasons for its evolution which are we the society itself. Today news happens every second and almost everywhere because today in the world the unusual happens is common or we can so say that making usual things unusual is very common.
But that is not the end , today social media has taken over all the other mediums of mass communication. All media houses are today in loop with the social media. By signing the treaties of supporting and helping each other both become interdependent as the other mediums like print and broadcast faced huge losses because of internet and thus had to surrender. Internet is the fastest medium to get updated with news and information, a daily news paper has its own limitations and appears once everyday with maximum news and information of the previous day and the broadcast takes hours where the news is gathered edited and then broadcasted. But internet is faster than both it takes seconds to post any news or updates and also rectify the previous mistakes or share current updates.
This has increased the options and has also given a scope to the journalists to  perform unethical as it is very easy to refer different sites and sources of internet and form his own story thus here the journalist compromises with the ethics and thus do it. The story you read or see is not covered by the journalist but is a piece of unethical or in today's time smart work.

Some where there is the society responsible for this as the increasing population and various demands have made the media helpless as it is the fourth estate ait has to survive no matter how ethically or unethically. And as we know that media influences people in many ways , people are also getting used and attracted to the so called smart work in the day to day life and thus the ground reality is buried deep today what we see is illusion of wrong and incorrect.